A roof is an important investment for your home, and there are a lot of factors to consider when deciding on what type of roof you want. Aesthetics, eco-friendliness, and your safety during extreme weather are all key elements in the decision making process. When it comes to roofing materials, metal and shingle roofs are two of the most popular choices. Each has advantages and disadvantages that lead homeowners to choose one over the other.

Shingles tend to be cheaper to install and replace and come in a wide range of designs to match any aesthetic. On the other hand, a metal roof is more expensive but offers durability and longevity that may outlast shingle roofing. Which one you choose ultimately depends on your budget and priorities.

Less Expensive to Install & Replace – Because shingles are prepackaged and ready for immediate nailing to the roof deck (unless cuts are required), they require less time, labor, and skill than metal panels. This is a major advantage of shingles over metal roofing, which requires more handling of finished panels and connections between them and the flashing. This can be challenging for contractors who are not used to working with these materials.

Easier to Repair – Unlike the solid, interconnected nature of metal roofing panels, shingles can be removed and replaced one at a time for smaller repairs. This makes it easier and less expensive for consumers to find contractors who are qualified to work on their shingles. In addition, because shingles are much more common than metal roofs, they have more available repair and replacement resources.

More Durable – Typically made of a combination of steel, aluminum, copper, or tin, metal roofs are able to withstand harsh conditions better than shingle roofs. They can be resistant to fire, wind, rain, and hail, which is a big plus for areas prone to hurricanes, tornadoes, and other natural disasters.

Added Value to Your Home – Since they are more durable than shingle roofs, many homeowners feel that metal roofs add an extra level of security to the property and increase its resale value. Some insurance companies may even offer discounts on your insurance if you have a metal roof installed.

Aesthetics

– While shingles have improved in recent years to be lighter and more colorful, they still do not offer the same sleek, modern appearance of a metal roof. They also have a more “rustic” look than the corrugated tin panels that evoke images of barns and sheds.

However, for those who prioritize affordability and a wide array of design options, shingle roofs are the best choice. They are also a good option for those who live in communities with strict homeowners associations that require certain colors or types of materials for home components. While these limitations exist, they are not insurmountable and can be overcome with the right planning and design. Aside from these practical concerns, a metal vs shingle roof is also an excellent option for many homes.